Soldat Registrat - are these 2 listings the same?

[Victoria Cihla]

In researching an ancestor Måns Andersson Weckman on the soldat registrat - I've found two similar listings:

Centrala Soldatregistret
Tillbaka till träfflistan
Soldaten
Övriga soldater vid rote/rusthåll
WECKMAN?BECKMAN? Måns
Släktnamn: Andersson
Född: 1688
Död: -
Antagen: 1710
Avsked: 1728
Aktnummer: KR-06-0782-1710
Regemente: Kronobergs regemente
Rote: Tommaryd
Kompani: SÖDRA SUNNERBO
Socken: HINNERYD
Torpnummer: KR-06-0782
Det kan finnas mer uppgifter om soldaten än vad som visas här t.ex. familjebild eller andra värdefulla upplysningar. Kontakta gärna registret nedan för mer information. Ange soldatens namn och aktnummer.KontaktinformationKRONOBERGS SOLDATREGISTERJörgen Sjöblom,Framnäsvägen 27 f352 39 Växjöjs53@tele2.seAvgift: 100:- pr/akt vid vanlig post frankerat kuvertSoldatregistret är en andrahandskälla. Användaren ansvarar för kontroll av uppgifterna mot originalkällorna. Informationen ur registret citeras som "Centrala soldatregistret".
Soldater vid torp med nummer: KR-06-0782


ANDERSSON MÅNS
Family name: -
Born: 1700
Death: -
Adopted: 1718
Farewell: -
File number: KR-06-0782-1718
Regiment: Kronoberg's regiment
Rote: Tommaryd (94)
Company : SÖDRA SUNNERBO
Parish : HINNERYD
Farm number: KR-06-0782
There may be more information about the soldier than is shown here, e.g. family picture or other valuable information. Please contact the registry below for more information. Enter the soldier's name and file number.
Contact information
KRONOBERG SOLDIER REGISTERJörgen SjöblomFramnäsvägen 27 F352 39 Växjö070-53 12 584
53jorgen@gmail.comgenealogy.se/kgfSEK 100 per item for regular mail, stamped envelope.
Other soldiers at rote/rust hold (show)

Are these the same person? 

I recently found a GMR record that lists a Måns Andersson Weckman for the year 1733.  Any help with the annotation on this record would be greatly appreciated in trying to understand why, when according to the first soldat record, he was discharged in 1728. 

1728 GMR record:   Generalmönsterrullor - Kronobergs regemente (G) 333a (1728) Image 408 (AID: v46672a.b408, NAD: SE/KrA/0023)
                              https://app.arkivdigital.se/volume/v46672a?image=408

1733 GMR record:  Generalmönsterrullor - Kronobergs regemente (G) 334 (1733) Image 226 (AID: v46673.b226, NAD: SE/KrA/0023)
                             https://app.arkivdigital.se/volume/v46673?image=226

Can anyone tell me if these 2 records are for the same man based on this information? I may have misunderstood something somewhere....

Thanks for any help with this!

Vicki

[Staffan Bergh]

The second record is some kind of mistake ...

Måns Andersson Weckman, born about 1688 (40 years old in 1728), is released from duty ("får afskied") at the muster in 1728, after 19 years of service, on the strength of a note ("attest") from his employers, the farmers of the "rote" -- a note that says he is aged and weak.

At the muster in 1733 the writer -- following the usual process when something has changed -- first mentions what was written in the previous roll, and then goes on to say that Måns has been replaced by Nils Jonsson Hindh, who is 38 years old and has served for 22 years.

[Victoria Cihla]

Hi Staffan,

It was very confusing so I really appreciate your information!

Thanks very much,

Vicki